Sunday, September 27, 2020

Rising of the Shield Hero - manga volume 2 (read for fun)

Rising of the Shield Hero - manga volume 2

By the time I read this, I had read the first volume of the light novels and watched part of the first anime season. For comparison, this manga volume covers about the second half of the first light novel and a couple episodes of the anime. This is Naofumi visiting the Dragon Hourglass for the first time, the Second Wave, and then his duel with Motoyatsu. Then, of course, the aftermath of said duel and Raphtalia's backstory. I don't really have much to say about this volume. 

It does an alright job of conveying the story. A reader will know enough of what happens to follow along when another real-life fan talks about it or when these events are referenced later in the story. However, its medium prevents it from conveying as much information as the light novel. Without knowledge outside the manga, a reader might not understand some things. The anime outshines it in visual appeal, providing more of a spectacle and adding emotion through voice acting. The manga just doesn't provide anything that the light novel or anime don't do better. 

This is not to say this volume is bad on its own merit. That is definitely not the case. The art looks good. The arrangement of cells moves the story along at a good clip, faster during action scenes and slower during more tender ones. The way that the aftermath of the Shield vs Spear duel is handled is particularly effective. Specifically, the way the manga presents Naofumi's realization of Raphtalia's true age and appearance captures the emotions he must be feeling at that point very well. 

I just recommend one of the other two mediums. 

Trickster Eric Novels gives "Rising of the Shield Hero - manga volume 2" a passing grade. 

Click here for my next book review:  Aria volume 1 masterpiece edition

Click here for my previous book review: The Royal Tutor volume

Brian Wilkerson is a independent novelist, freelance book reviewer, and writing advice blogger. He studied at the University of Minnesota and came away with bachelor degrees in English Literature and History (Classical Mediterranean Period concentration).

His fantasy series, Journey to Chaos, is currently available on Amazon as an ebook or paperback.

Sunday, September 20, 2020

The Royal Tutor volume 1 (Read for fun)

 The Royal Tutor volume 1

This is a manga I picked up at my local library. Check out your own. They likely have great stuff.  This story is a comedy about a tiny man, Professor Heine, teaching four difficult princes. This first volume is mainly set up. 

The professor arrives and meets the princes all at once, discovers that none of them want to be tutored by him, and then sets up interviews to get to know them better. That is the framework of this volume. It's a great framework because it plays to the strengths of this story. 

The characters are vivid and detailed, practically life-like. Even before the interviews that focus on each prince, they are distinct individuals. Trust me, it's difficult to set up five characters at the same time, while also introducing the setting and conflict of the story. Naturally, this distinction increases over the course the story. 

The traits initially introduced are developed further and further traits are added, complimenting and contrasting the original ones. As a result of Heine's interview with the prince, some conceptions are even turned around, revealing hidden depths. Of all the princes, it is hard to say which makes the most dramatic turn. My vote goes to Prince Bruno. 

It is a satisfying story that resolves its initial conflict.  

Though I wonder how much tutoring is going to happen in future volumes, the story addresses this as well. Heine states that his purpose as a tutor is not only to teach the princes academic subjects, but other subjects as well. It would appear he is intended to be something of a life coach, because the king considers all four of princes unfit to rule for reasons of their personalities. 

The artwork certainly looks good. In fact, I'd call it beautiful. It has this regal feel to it, fitting with its setting and premise, but it is occasionally softer and sillier for more comedic moments. 

And that is where my only complaint comes in. 

The story has a "Heine is tiny" running gag that I generally find to be lame. Some of them can be funny, such as when guards mistake him as the royal tutor's son, or palace ladies gush on how cute he is and he reacts favorably to the attention while remaining stoic. However, others are not funny.

 In fact, they exaggerate his tininess to the point where he seems to actually get even smaller than he already is, rather than just drawn smaller for comedic effect. The most egregious of these is when he rolls off his bed and gets stuck in the tiny space between his bed and the wall. He seriously can't move until a maid checks on him in the morning. That pushes the gag too far. 

Trickster Eric Novels gives The Royal Tutor volume 1 a B+

Click here for my next book review: Rising of the Shield Hero - manga volume 2

Click here for my previous book review: Sleepy Princess in Demon Castle

Brian Wilkerson is a independent novelist, freelance book reviewer, and writing advice blogger. He studied at the University of Minnesota and came away with bachelor degrees in English Literature and History (Classical Mediterranean Period concentration).

His fantasy series, Journey to Chaos, is currently available on Amazon as an ebook or paperback.

Sunday, September 13, 2020

Sleepy Princess in Demon Castle volume 1 (read for fun)

 Sleepy Princess in Demon Castle volume 1

This story comes recommended by Tvtropes, which called it a funny fantasy parody. I agree. This story has a familiar set-up, the princess of the Human Country has been kidnapped by the Demon King and held captive in his castle, so a human hero sets off to rescue her. However, this story is not about the hero's journey but the princess's attempt to get a good night's sleep. 

As a captive, Princess Syalis doesn't have much to do other than sleep and, as it turns out, her cell in Demon Castle serves as a poor bedroom. So she sets out to improve it by gathering materials for sleeping aids around the castle. This is the source of the manga's humor.

Every chapter has the same set-up: Princess Syalis has a sleeping problem, so she devises a solution and then works towards that solution. It is amazing how many different scenarios Kagiji Kumanomata can devise out of this framework, and how many different kinds of comedy can result. Some of it is fantasy parody (seeking a magic shield to use as an air mattress), some of it is comedic sociopathy (ghost shrouds make for great fabric) and some of it is based on sustained misunderstandings or dramatic irony.  As a result, I never found this set-up to be boring. 

Indeed, I looked forward to each chapter to see the new scenario because I was at a loss for what would come next after the pillow and bed sheet quests were complete. It is a slice-of-life series, so don't expect too much change from chapter to chapter, yet there are still signs of continuity. The reader is occasionally shown all previous sleep aids that the princess has collected so far, and the demons become progressively less alarmed when they see her out of her cell. One of them even escorts her to another area of the castle, because she asked nicely, as if she were the princess of "this" castle instead of is captive. 

The artwork is cute. The princess, of course, is adorable, but so are the teddy demons and some of the others, like the Poison Apple Men. The Demon Castle itself looks good, as well. It is definitely NOT cute, and this serves the purpose of the series's humor in a Comically-Serious sort of way, given the parody tone and the events that take place in it. 

I am definitely interested in volume 2

Trickster Eric Novels gives "Sleepy Princess in Demon Castle volume 1" an A+

Click here for my next book review: The Royal Tutor volume 1

Click here for my previous book review: Ah! My Goddess - omnibus #1

Brian Wilkerson is a independent novelist, freelance book reviewer, and writing advice blogger. He studied at the University of Minnesota and came away with bachelor degrees in English Literature and History (Classical Mediterranean Period concentration).

His fantasy series, Journey to Chaos, is currently available on Amazon as an ebook or paperback.

Wednesday, September 9, 2020

Ah! My Goddess - omnibus #1

 One of the upsides of the COVID-19 pandemic is that it led to me using the local library network's online catalog instead of browsing the selection available at the closest library building to me. This is because of a change in how books were being checked out at the time  (there is a new but similar process in place as of this writing, I think). You select a book and put a hold on it, and then the librarian puts your selection into a bag for you to pick up. This helps with social distancing. 

This means that the catalog for the entire library network opens up to me. I didn't know how to do this at the start of the year, so I might not have found this particular book. It is the first omnibus for the classic romantic comedy, Ah! My Goddess. It is chapter 1 through chapter 23. Up until now, I have only seen the OVA, so I was excited to see its roots. 

It was very interesting to see how the story began. Belldandy's design, for instance, is a lot different than what it would be when the anime started. Characters in-universe mistake her as being a traveler from India. Also, since Belldandy herself is initially the only supernatural character to be regularly present for many chapters, the story as a whole is more a low fantasy/urban fantasy than it would be in later arcs, when more goddesses and demons show up. This includes what I think is a narrow restriction on the number of times Belldandy can use her powers in one day. If she could use them freely, then she would solve every problem effortlessly, because no one else has any kind of power. 

Certain events in the early chapters are a different kind of interesting in light of the infamous plot twist that takes place late in the series; it is clearly a retcon BUT one can see where the origins of such an idea can be seen. Is it a coincidence or foreshadowing decades in the making? 

The chapters definitely get better over time. 

The introduction of different sorts of antagonists allows for different types of conflict, while providing opportunities for hilarity to ensue as this conflict happens to Keichi. Sayoko Mishima tries to steal Keichi, Toshiyuki Aoshima tries to steal Belldandy, and Urd is actually trying to be helpful to Keichi and Belldandy but causes trouble because she is "The Exchanger of Means and Ends". In other words, she has a good intention but gets carried anyway in how she fulfills that intention. Occasionally, there is a motor vehicle race, and those are also fun. 

So the comedy follows the duo's responses to these conflicts, and Keichi is usually the butt of the jokes. Indeed, it is as if the Yggdrasil system is balancing the tremendous good fortune of having a girlfriend like Belldandy with lots of comedic misfortunes. My favorite is when he takes a part-time job as a monster for a Tokusatsu superhero show, only to discover when the rest of the cast has left that he can't work the zipper on his costume, so he decides to wander the street and beg a stranger for help. That scenario had me in stitches for several minutes. 

On another note, regarding the story's romance aspect, I thought it was odd that the earliest phase of Belldandy and Keichi's relationship is glossed over. The first three chapters are their first full day together, and then the next two chapters cover (I think) several months. So by chapter 6 or so, they are definitively a couple, and acting like it. I think I like it better that way. 

Rare is it that I find a manga that quickly establishes its official couple as official so quickly. Most go for the Will-They-Or-Won't-They route, so a reader is lucky to see as much as an attempted confession by the end of the series. This one shows an actual relationship, such as the two of them going on dates, working together on projects, and Keichi looking for a meaningful way to mark their one year anniversary together. So while I didn't see why they fell in love, I get to see chapter after chapter of them actually being in love, which few series are willing to do. 

Trickster Eric Novels gives Ah! My Goddess -  omnibus #1 an A+

Click here for my previous book review: Sleepy Princess in Demon Castle (read for fun)

Click here for my previous book review: Dungeon and Dragons 5th Edition Dungeon Master's Guide

Brian Wilkerson is a independent novelist, freelance book reviewer, and writing advice blogger. He studied at the University of Minnesota and came away with bachelor degrees in English Literature and History (Classical Mediterranean Period concentration).

His fantasy series, Journey to Chaos, is currently available on Amazon as an ebook or paperback.

Monday, September 7, 2020

Critical Role inspired multi class character- Rogue-Ranger Assassin.

I've been thinking about a Ranger/Rogue multi class for Dungeons and Dragons fifth edition lately. It started with the Critical Role episode, Heredity and Hats, where Vax and Vex's half-sister Velora is introduced to the audience. She's adorable. Unlike her father, she thinks her elder siblings are the coolest people ever, and wears an owlbear feather that Vex gave her.

One of the Youtube comments for the episode talked about the idea of playing Grown-Up Velora in their home game. She would be both a rogue and a ranger to take after both siblings, and she would have an owlbear as a beast companion. I don't know how the latter option would work out, because the lore states that owlbear are thoroughly aggressive and ill-tempered, and their Challenge Rating is much higher than a bear like Trinket. However, the multi-class intrigued me because of its potential synergy.

Both rangers and rogues are a light-weapons-and-armor class, so using Dexterity as the chief weapon stat would work for both finesse and ranged weapons (daggers and longbow, of course).  Both classes benefit most from studded leather armor in regards to mundane armor, so that fits with the build. DEX is also the stat governing Stealth, which  suits both a ranger stalking prey in the wild and a rogue stalking a humanoid mark in a crowd.

Rangers use Wisdom as their spellcasting stat, and this stat is also useful for rogues. For what rogue would not appreciate the boost to their Insight checks when running a con, or to their Perception when they are sneaking about an active fortress or a dungeon inhabited by monstrous humanoids? So a player can boost DEX and WIS without worrying about their character becoming Multiple Ability Dependent.

As I explored further, I discovered more synergy. It was really quite fun to find all the little mechanical details to support the idea of roleplaying as the younger half-sister of famous adventurers. Roleplaying a particular character idea is fun, but it can become frustrating if the character's build is not viable mechanically (like the Hill-dwarf guild-artisan CHA focused paladin I'm currently playing).

Rangers can cast Pass Without A Trace to boost their roguish stealth ability, which they can choose to have expertise in. Thus, they can be like Vax and appear to disappear. Furthermore, as a ranger they can cast Hunter's Mark and therefore boost the potential harm of their Sneak Attack. Said player would just have to remember to cast it  (^_^) and add the damage of the former to each attack and the damage of the latter to only their first. 

This is still the early levels.

At level 5, a ranger gets Extra Attack, which a rogue does not. This means our hypothetical Grown-Up! Velora would be able to "Dagger! Dagger! Dagger!" even without Boots of Haste active.

Beyond that, the synergy would depend on what kind of Ranger/Rogue hybrid our hypothetical Velora would want to be. There are many possibilities in archetypes between the classes, depending on what sort of adventures she expected to get into story-wise, or how her player wanted her to develop mechanically. 

If this hypothetical Velora wanted to be an assassin like her big brother, then choosing "humanoid" as her ranger Favored Enemy would add to the damage boost she would gain from the Assassinate ability (Ranger -  Revised version). With all her other benefits, she would be able to reliably drop most standard humanoid NPCs without being seen or giving away her presence. 

Going for the Hunter conclave as a ranger would give her an even bigger boost to damage output, and thereby enable her to quickly finish off assassination targets if they happen to survive the initial death strike. At the same time, it could enable her to stay in the fight longer with its defensive features, and add to those of the Rogue (Escape the Horde, Uncanny Dodge, Evasion). I like to visual all this as her being too nimble to be hit and taunting the enemy with, "Too slow!"

However, if our hypothetical Velora wanted to emulate her big sister instead, then she could take the Scout archetype as a rogue, and gain more features for fighting, tracking and navigating. Together with Favored Enemy and Natural Explorer, nothing would be able to escape her and she is unlucky to ever get lost. She could still be sneaky by investing in the Gloom Stalker ranger conclave, learning its features to hide and kill from the shadows.

Perhaps this version of Velora got involved with a drow conflict. Now doesn't that sound interesting! The only child of an eleven nobleman and ambassador, hunting dark elves through pretty words at formal events and sneak attacks in some dark and empty tunnel.

 "House Vessar sends its regards. Rest in peace."

Now I want to write a fanfiction about that scenario. Maybe someone else already has. I'll have to check.

Anyway, that is just one scenario that I envisioned with this idea for a character build. I seriously might use in a future campaign because it sounds fun. I doubt I'll pretend to be Velora herself, partially because I don't think I could roleplay someone as cute as her and partially because I like the idea of her figuring out how to tame owlbears and then cuddling them rather than assassinating drow. It depends on what happens to her as she grows older. 

Oh! She would outlive her siblings, wouldn't she? Being fully elven and all, but that is neither here nor there for the mechanics of the build. 

If use a different character for character personality, should I keep the noble background? To keep with the idea of the build, I would have to choose one that boosts both ranger and rogue. I'll look into that too. 

Brian Wilkerson is a independent novelist, freelance book reviewer, and writing advice blogger. He studied at the University of Minnesota and came away with bachelor degrees in English Literature and History (Classical Mediterranean Period concentration).

His fantasy series, Journey to Chaos, is currently available on Amazon as an ebook or paperback.